Friday, October 28, 2011

Sarah Robertson, CPA had been the auditor of Majestic Co. for several years

ACCOUNTING

Auditing P 5-27 Sarah Robertson, CPA had been the auditor of Majestic Co. for several years. As she and her staff prepared for the audit for the year ended December 31, 2008, Herb Majestic told her that he needed a large bank loan to "tide him over" until sales picked up as expected late 2009. In the course of the audit, Robertson discovered that the financial situation at Majestic was worse than Majestic had revealed and that the company was technically bankrupt. She discussed the situation with Majestic, who pointed out that the bank loan will "be his solution"-he was sure he will get it as long as the financial statements don't look too bad. Robertson stated that she believed the statements will have to include a going concern explanatory paragraph, Majestic said that this wasn't needed because the bank loan was so certain and that inclusion of the going concern paragraph will certainly cause the management of the bank to change its mind about the loan. Robertson finally acquiesced and the audited statements were issued without a going concern paragraph. The company received the loan, but things did not improve as Majestic thought they would and the company filed for bankruptcy in August 2009. The bank sued Sarah Robertson for fraud. Required: Indicate whether or not you think the bank will succeed. Support your answer.

Click here for the SOLUTION